You may not agree with this, but “write what you know” is good advice. It’s one of the oldest tips in the writing world for a reason.
The problem isn’t the tip. It’s the box we keep putting it in.
My point: You’ve (hopefully) never murdered anyone. So how are you supposed to write a scene where your character disembowels someone? If “write what you know” only mean you’ve personally done, that scene would (definitely should) be off-limits. So would most of the fantasy, thriller, and horror shelves.
Where the box comes from
Most writers read “write what you know” like a résumé. You job (receptionist, nurse, barista). Your degree. The town you grew up in. The year you learned to drive.
Those things are useful. Lived detail makes a scene feel real, and nobody writes a hospital break room like someone who’s eaten lunch in one.
But taken literally, the résumé reading falls apart fast. Nobody writing epic fantasy has ridden a dragon. Nobody writing sci-fi has crewed a generation ship. Thriller writers aren’t (usually) assassins, and horror writers haven’t actually been hunted through the woods (if you have…I’m so sorry that happened, yet I’m madly curious on hearing your experience).
If the tip only meant lived events, entire genres couldn’t exist. So it has to mean something else.
What “know” actually means
You don’t need to have done it. You need to have felt it.
What you know can include experience (sure), but the tip is really pointing at the emotions you’ve lived through. Fear. Shame. Rage. Relief. The sick drop in your stomach when you realize you can’t take something back.
You’ve never plunged a sword into someone (if you did, do not tell me). But you know panic. You know what a point of no return feels like. You probably know (even in small, ordinary doses) what power and control feel like, and what it costs to grab them.
That’s the material. Readers can forgive you for not knowing how heavy a longsword is (very heavy). What they won’t forgive is a character who kills someone for the first time and feels nothing on the page. (Yikes.)
How to use what you know
How I’d approach any scene you haven’t lived:
Name the core emotion. I’m not talking “it’s a fight scene.” I’m talking: What does your character feel before, during, and after? Panic? Triumph? Disgust at how good to triumph feels?
Find your moment. Look for a time in your own life when you felt something close to it. It doesn’t need to match in size. A screaming argument you couldn’t walk back can carry the same cahrge as a battlefield.
Pull out the physical details. What did you body do? Your heartbeat, your hands, what you noticed in the room, the thought you couldn’t stop circling. Those specifics are what make emotion believable on the page.
Scale it up. Take that real feeling and turn the volume up to fit your story’s stakes. The texture stays honest even when the situation is invented.
What this looks like in practice
The first kill (fantasy). Your character has to plunge a sword into their first victim, for a good reason or a bad one Skip the choreography for a second and ask what they feel. Before: dread, maybe a flicker of disbelief that this is really happening. During: the point of no return. After: power, control, or a hollow ringing they can’t name. You’ve felt version of all of those.
The betrayal (court intrigue). You’ve probably never been sold out to a rival kingdom. But you may know what it’s like to find out a friend talked about you behind your back, and to replay every conversation you’d had with them. That replaying is the scene.
The dread (horror). You’ve never been stalked by something inhuman. But you’ve lain awake sure you heard a noise downstairs. You know the way your ears strain in silence, and how long thirty second can feel. Give your character that.
Feelings don’t replace research
One caveat, because I’d be doing you a disservice without it. Emotional truth doesn’t let you skip the facts.
You still need to know what a sword wound actually does to a body, how long it takes someone to bleed out, and whether your character could realistically walk away from that fight. Get those wrong and readers who do know will be pulled right out of the story.
Think of it as two layers. Research gets the details right. Your own emotions make readers care about them. A scene needs both.
Try it
Pick one scene in your manuscript that feels flat. Write down the single emotion it needs most. Then spend five minutes freewriting about a real moment when you felt that emotion. Don’t worry about your character yet. Just capture what your body did and what you noticed.
Now go back to the scene and give your character one of those details. Watch what happens.
If you want more craft fundamentals like this, my Foundations Guide walks through the building blocks every writer needs.
Stop putting “write what you know” in a box. You know more than you think.
Don’t Crush my Crumb™ 🥐
✌🏼 & 🖤 ,

